Welcome to this year’s edition of Winter Case Notes in which I highlight a collection of recent court decisions of interest to business divorce aficionados by way of brief synopses with links to the decisions for those who...more
2/24/2020
/ Appeals ,
Article III ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Corporate Dissolution ,
Demand Futility ,
Derivative Suit ,
Shareholder Demands ,
Shareholder Litigation ,
Standing ,
Statute of Limitations ,
Time-Barred Claims
I’ve yet to see him make a court appearance, and hope I never do, but the Grim Reaper sure has a knack for disrupting business divorce litigation involving LLCs and limited partnerships....more
2/10/2020
/ Assignments ,
Automatic Stay ,
Breach of Duty ,
Business Disputes ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Commercial Court ,
Controlling Person ,
Decedent Protection ,
Derivative Suit ,
Dissolution ,
Family Businesses ,
Fiduciary Duty ,
Fraud ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Limited Partnerships ,
Ownership Interest ,
Partnership Interests ,
Partnerships ,
Real Estate Market ,
Statutory Interpretation ,
Transfer of Control ,
Unfair Dealing
The case of Shapiro v Ettenson ranks as one of the more consequential ones in the realm of New York’s LLC jurisprudence....more
2/4/2020
/ Arbitration ,
Bad Faith ,
Breach of Contract ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Capital Calls ,
Contract Disputes ,
Contract Terms ,
Damages ,
Expulsion ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Member Removal ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements
Not for the first time, I find myself intrigued by the federal courts’ resistance to hearing state law claims for judicial dissolution of business entities where subject matter jurisdiction otherwise exists based on diversity...more
1/13/2020
/ Breach of Duty ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Entities ,
Business Litigation ,
Commercial Court ,
Commercial Leases ,
Common Law Claims ,
Contract Renewal ,
Damages ,
Derivative Suit ,
Dissolution ,
Fiduciary Duty ,
First Impression ,
Holding Companies ,
Investment ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Nonprofits ,
Shareholder Litigation ,
Shareholder Rights ,
Shareholders ,
State Law Claims ,
Statutory Interpretation ,
Statutory Violations ,
Subject Matter Jurisdiction ,
Unjust Enrichment
In the end, it wasn’t much of a fight.
The case of Huggins v Scott, decided last month by Justice W. Franc Perry of the Manhattan Supreme Court, illustrates anew the well-nigh insurmountable hurdle faced by a minority...more
12/9/2019
/ Books & Records ,
Breach of Duty ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Contract Disputes ,
Fiduciary Duty ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements ,
Receivership
I’ve lost track of how many lawsuits I’ve seen between co-owners of New York City restaurants. It’s not surprising given the high percentage of restaurant failures in an intensely competitive market with high rents, high...more
12/2/2019
/ Books & Records ,
Business Assets ,
Business Litigation ,
Commercial Court ,
Contract Terms ,
Dismissals ,
Fraud Abuse and Waste ,
Intellectual Property Protection ,
IP License ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Operating Agreements ,
Partnerships ,
Professional Misconduct ,
Restaurant Industry ,
Theft ,
Trademarks
In 2018, two members of a realty holding LLC sought judicial dissolution based on the death of one of the other members. The operating agreement defines a member’s death as an event of “Dissociation.”...more
11/18/2019
/ Appeals ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Contract Disputes ,
Contract Negotiations ,
Contract Terms ,
Decedent Protection ,
Dismissals ,
Dissolution ,
Inheritance ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements ,
Property Valuation ,
Real Estate Market ,
Rental Property
330 West 85th Street is a prime location on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. At that address sits an elegant, pre-war, 48-unit rental apartment building known as The Rexmere. A 4th floor one-bedroom apartment currently is...more
In my business divorce travels occasionally I encounter instances in which shareholder distributions are made in the period between the valuation date for an elective buyout of a minority shareholder who sued for dissolution...more
The nationwide landscape of statutes and case law governing judicial dissolution of limited liability companies exhibits more state-to-state similarity than dissimilarity....more
9/23/2019
/ Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Buyouts ,
Capital Contributions ,
Contract Terms ,
Corporate Purpose ,
Dissolution ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements ,
Sale of Assets ,
Statutory Interpretation
Parking lots breed partnership disputes. I’ve litigated them and I’ve written about them, most notably the Kassab saga.
I suppose it’s the untapped development potential of parking lots, especially in flourishing downtown...more
It’s commonly said there are three things that matter with real estate: location, location, location. Likewise, three things matter when choosing a lawyer to set up a limited liability company: experience,...more
6/18/2019
/ Agribusiness ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Formation ,
Business Litigation ,
Business Partners ,
Dissolution ,
Family Businesses ,
Farms ,
K-1 ,
Legal Representatives ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Operating Agreements ,
Transfer of Interest
I’ve long been intrigued with the frequency of litigation — especially in Delaware Chancery Court — over advancement of legal fees of a corporate director or officer or LLC manager who’s the target of a lawsuit by the entity...more
5/28/2019
/ Advancement ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Commercial Court ,
Contract Terms ,
Corporate Dissolution ,
Corporate Officers ,
Directors ,
Indemnification ,
Indemnification Clauses ,
Legal Fees ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Stock Options
As it approaches its sixth anniversary with little sign of letting up, the highly contentious litigation between brothers and business partners NIssim and Avraham Kassab is the gift that keeps on giving, at least to us...more
The litigation arsenal of business divorce lawyers contains weapons of varying firepower. The choice of weapon for any particular assignment will depend on many factors including the type and size of the business; whether the...more
When a minority shareholder petitions for judicial dissolution under § 1104-a of the Business Corporation Law based on the majority’s alleged oppressive conduct, looting, waste, or diversion of corporate assets, BCL § 1118...more
What’s a weaponized LLC? It’s one whose operating agreement gives the controlling majority members the authority to dilute, remove from management, or expel a non-controlling minority member, typically for failing to satisfy...more
Very few and very far between are cases in which the holder of a minority membership interest in a New York LLC — with or without a written operating agreement — prevails in an action brought under section 702 of the New York...more
The dog days of August are upon us, a perfect time as I do each year to offer vacationing readers some lighter fare consisting of summaries of a few recent decisions of interest involving disputes between business co-owners....more
8/13/2018
/ Appraisal ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Business Valuations ,
Buy-Out Agreements ,
Co-Ownership ,
Contract Disputes ,
Contract Terms ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Jurisdiction ,
NE Supreme Court ,
Partnership Agreements ,
Partnership Interests ,
Partnerships ,
Profit Sharing ,
Shareholders
Shareholders A and B are the sole shareholders of a real estate holding corporation. Their shareholders’ agreement includes provisions that...more
The hard-fought business divorce litigation between Nissim Kassab and his brother Avraham has provided plenty of fodder for this blog over the last several years with more to come, as evidenced by Queens County Supreme Court...more
Mediation, as commonly understood in the context of alternative dispute resolution, employs a neutral third party to facilitate negotiation and voluntary agreement between the parties. Unlike arbitration, the mediator does...more
The Nobel Prize symbolizes the apex of human achievement in the arts and sciences. It is no guarantee, however, that its recipients are equally adept when it comes to their own business endeavors....more
You know there’s something unusual going on in a case involving a dispute between co-members of an LLC — a form of business entity that didn’t exist in New York until 1994 — when the key legal precedents cited in the parties’...more
The family-owned business at the center of Vaccari v Vaccari, 2018 NY Slip Op 30546(U) [Sup Ct NY County Mar. 28, 2018], decided last month by veteran Manhattan Commercial Division Justice Eileen Bransten, is a classic...more
4/9/2018
/ Accounting ,
Attorney's Fees ,
Breach of Duty ,
Business Litigation ,
Commercial Court ,
Conversion ,
Dissolution ,
Divorce ,
Failure To State A Claim ,
Family Businesses ,
Fiduciary Duty ,
Injunctive Relief ,
Joint Venture ,
Motion to Dismiss ,
Shareholder Oppression ,
Summary Judgment ,
Unjust Enrichment